Thursday, February 10, 2011
Essay One
When I view this picture I am looking at a time in my life where I learned an invaluable lesson of love, patience, and friendship. The picture includes my husband Michael, my dear friend Rob, and me. This picture was taken at a party in celebration of Rob’s return from Iraq.
It is important to provide the history between Rob and I. We met ten years earlier at a coffee shop; we had similar interests, and became instant friends. Three years after our friendship began we started dating. We were extremely young yet our dating blossomed into a committed relationship. During the four years we dated we shared a home. The relationship did not last but the friendship remained intact. Our friends were amazed that we had the ability to continue forward with our friendship. I believe we set a good example when we showed how the dissolution of a committed relationship could be. I was really happy that I did not lose my best friend just because our dating relationship ended. Rob did not have the traditional family growing up; he felt like needed some stability, direction, and support in his life. He decided to join the marines. I was very proud of Rob yet concerned for his safety.
I was playing pool a few weeks before Rob shipped off to boot camp and I met a man named Michael. He was charming and bold but at that time I was not interested in meeting anyone so I was not responsive to his advances. He was extremely persistent and possessed a great amount of charisma. We clicked instantly after I gave him a chance. During our conversations I told him about Rob. Michael completely understood and respected my friendship with Rob.
When I told Rob about Michael he encouraged me to embrace the idea of dating Michael. Unfortunately Michael lived in California. He was in Utah assisting his mother with some home projects for a few months. During those few months I realized that Michael was important to me but I knew he would be leaving soon. After he went back to California we spoke nearly everyday and we both looked forward to his next visit. A few months later we made the decision to date long distance. After a year and many flights back and forth between Salt Lake City and San Francisco we determined it was time for one of us to relocate. Michael had a son living in California therefore it was up to me to move. I was excited for new surroundings but was sad to leave my family and friends. Seven months before the big move Michael came to visit and proposed to me. We were married in 2004 in Salt Lake City, Utah surrounded by family and friends. Rob was on leave from the marines and we both chose him to be one of our groomsmen. We will never forget our magical day of celebration.
Two years later we met Rob at the Salt Lake City, Utah airport. We gathered together a network of friends and family to surprise him and welcome him back from fighting in Iraq. I believe he was overwhelmed to see so many people who supported him through his deployment. After the airport we gathered to celebrate at our house. I was somewhat concerned someone would ask Rob a question he might not be ready to answer, but everyone was just ready to celebrate his return. As the evening winded down Rob shared some pictures and videos he had taken in Iraq. He explained the stories behind the images and we were moved by his courageousness. He lost many friends on the battleground of Iraq and reviewing the pictures made him feel those emotions that were stuffed deep inside.
The history of my relationship with Rob and Michael provides evidence that we all give each other social roles in life, such as ex-boyfriend, friend, or husband. With social roles comes an expectation of who that person is to us and what they mean in our life. I defied the social role of ex-partner. I do not believe in cutting a person out of your life because they are no longer your significant other. There is a reason you originally fell in love. How is it possible to dismiss your best friend because a romantic relationship did not work out?
My picture reflects the significant connections we make with certain people in this life and how important it is to hold tight to these relationships throughout social role changes. I know I made the right choice for me when I chose to ignore societies expectations of social roles.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Sarah,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your essay. I think it's very cool that you remained friends with an ex-boyfriend. It's also very admirable that your husband was able to accept your friendship with your friend, Rob. I can see what you mean when you say that just because you're no longer romantically involved, you can't continue to be good friends. If both are willing and able to remain friends, there shouldn't be any reason not to be.
From a critical point of view, I think your essay is strong. I can identify the thesis and your background information on the nature of your relationship with your friend and your husband support it well. By reading your essay I can definitely see the significance of the photograph.
Good job!
Hi Sarah,
ReplyDeleteIt seems that you are very broadminded person. Its not only your friends, I am amazed of your relation too. Things are little different for me I tend to totally ignore my Ex, even though we end up in the same class. In fact I am very narrow minded person, your essay really made me think twice.
I was not able to locate your thesis statement at first or second paragraph as I thought would appear but as I went on I could find it in your sixth paragraph where you talk about giving a social role to our Exs in our life.
The friendship maintained between you and your ex-boyfriend surely supports the thesis. In fact it is the strong evidence of giving social role to a person whom you tend to or are forced to forget about.
The things I found strong about the essay is the clarity of the theme and the way it is written. It is like reading a story, very clear and simple words are presented in systematic and corresponding manner
Sujan.
Hi Sarah,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your essay. You are a very brave and courageous. It's an amazing story you wrote. If it wasn't for you and your husband being open minded about relationships your friendship with your ex wouldn't have been possible.
Your thesis was noticeable. Your story flowed very nicely. It caught the audiences attention. Your supporting thesis was easily found and supported.
I agree with Sujan that your essay may benefit from having your thesis in the first paragraph. It was hard to find.
Hi Sarah,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your essay. It was a sweet story that made me smile. It's great that you were able to stay friend with an ex and that you found a husband that wasn't bothered by it.
Your essay is really strong and I really see what this photograph means to you. Your thesis was also very clear.
As for suggestions, I can't think of any.
- Sara Nogueiro
Hello Sarah,
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing your story. I enjoyed reading about your friendships and relationships. Although some may find remaining friends with an ex-boyfriend an awkward situation, I have a similar experience. It took years of being apart and recovering from the pain but now we are best of friends. It is almost like we are brother and sister.
Your thesis and supporting details came across very clear.
Good job.
Mandy Ericson
Sara, thank you so much for your feed back on my essay!
ReplyDeleteStacy