My relationship with my father and Sarah’s relationship with her father in “Shooting Dad” are particularly similar. We both grew up not appreciating our fathers for the wonderful role models they were yet thankfully we both recognized our critical error before it was too late.
Sarah’s relationship with her father became strained after her first experience with his enthusiasm for guns. Her lack of appreciation for his love of guns eventually developed into a dislike for his political beliefs. Similarly, my relationship became strained with my father when I started developing my own views on life and religious ideals that were opposite of what my father believed. Sarah’s father embraced the concept of his daughter developing her own ideas, theories, and political beliefs. My father was horrified at the idea of his first-born daughter not following each principle he taught her.
When I realized it was time for me to explore the world and investigate different types of beliefs, it caused my father to fear for my future. I wanted to investigate if what my father had taught me was in fact the truth or if I would be able to find something else that was a better fit for me. On my sixteenth birthday our relationship reached the boiling point, my father outlined his distaste for my interests, style, and beliefs. He had an image of an ideal daughter trapped in his head and was unwilling to expand his concept to include the reality of what I had become. He started trying to enforce rules to squash my individualism that he viewed as rebellion. I reacted in a way a teenager would, by creating a persona reeking of hatred for authority.
Sarah and I reacted to our fathers in a similar way, we both chose to participate in a lifestyle that was completely opposite of what our parental figures lived. Sarah chased music, art, and liberal politics. I chased loud music, cigarettes, and general rebelliousness.
Both Sarah and I realized later in life how important it is to have a good relationship with your father. I finally saw my father as a human being, a person with thoughts, feelings, and emotions. I realized he is allowed to make mistakes. Just like Sarah was able to finally see how similar her and her father were, I was able to see the similarities between my father and I. My father and I both felt strong about our ideals and were willing to stand up for what we believe in. We are both quick to voice our opinion and stand firm regardless of outside influences. In fact I now believe I gained my character by watching my father. We may not see eye to eye on every issue but we have respect and love for each other.
Sarah and I tried desperately to be entirely different from our fathers and in retrospect we instead both possessed multiple similarities and convictions.
Hello, What’s strong about the essay? You essay is strong, it has details that explain your purpose of the relation between you can sarah. What else could the writer cite as evidence in this essay? A quote should be mention to fully express your position. overall your essay is great. Just need a little more text.
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry to hear about you and your father. I'm glad you saw a good side to him and his mistakes were mistakes.
Thank YOU, Lesley
Hi Sara,
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to say that I liked how open and honest you were about your relationship with your father. I like how you shared that you wanted to investigate if what your father had taught you was in fact the truth or if you would be able to find something else that was a better fit for you. You gave many great examples of your relationship with your father. You might want to quote some of Sarah Vowell difficulties with her father, so that you can tie them into the ones you have shared. You also state that your dad was a wonderful role model, I think you might was to share some ensamples of how he was such a wonderful role model. One of the questions is what the writers’ thesis. I think your thesis statement might be. We both grew up not appreciating our fathers for the wonderful role models they were yet thankfully we both recognized our critical error before it was too late. Sara thanks again for sharing your story and heart.
Stacy
It is during our teenage years that we need to be controlled most because this is the time when we chose our direction and choosing wrong direction may cost us our future. We also find our ideas completely different form our parents at this age. Once we are matured we will understand the differences.
ReplyDeleteI could find your thesis statement in the first paragraph where you mentioned growing up not appreciating each other. Even though you’re writing are leading to thesis there are little flaws. You haven’t exactly mentioned the difference in ideas and have not presented any events or evidence of differences like Sarah did on her essay. You have just described you and your father has differences but haven’t mention how. Your conclusion paragraph seems to be little short.
Reading your essay I felt it was a very strong essay. You have your thesis following very strong supportive paragraphs. If there were something to work on I would recommend your conculsion but besides that, it was great! Reading it gives me thoughts on how to better my essay since we wrote about the same thing.:-) I do believe teenage years are so important in needing direction. I have two teen age sons today and they definitely need me home to be giving them direction. I remember someone telling me a long time ago, you need to be home with your kids when they are older not when they are younger. Boy, that comment really stuck with me and how true it was. Thanks for sharing. I hope this helps.
ReplyDeleteDina Dodd